Chattel Mortgage vs Finance Lease: Which Is Right for Your Business?
Published: February 2026 By: Jorden Harris, Commercial Finance Broker
When a business needs to finance a vehicle, piece of equipment, or machinery, the two most common structures are a chattel mortgage and a finance lease. Both achieve the same goal — getting your business the asset without paying cash upfront — but they work very differently from an ownership, accounting, and tax perspective.
This guide breaks down the differences so you can work with your accountant to choose the right structure for your business.
What Is a Chattel Mortgage?
A chattel mortgage is a business loan secured against a moveable asset (the "chattel") — typically a vehicle, plant, or equipment. The key feature is that your business owns the asset from day one, with the lender holding a mortgage over it as security.
How it works:
1. You take out a loan for the purchase price of the asset
2. Your business is registered as the owner (on the PPSR and/or vehicle registry)
3. You make regular repayments over the agreed term (typically 1–7 years)
4. The lender's mortgage is discharged once the loan is fully repaid
5. Optional: a residual/balloon payment at the end of the term
What Is a Finance Lease?
A finance lease is a rental arrangement where the lender (or finance company) owns the asset, and your business leases it for an agreed term in exchange for regular payments. At the end of the lease, you typically have options to:
- Purchase the asset at a residual value
- Return the asset
- Refinance the residual
- Extend the lease
The defining feature is that you don't own the asset during the lease term — it sits on the finance company's balance sheet.
Key Differences
Feature Chattel Mortgage Finance Lease
-----------------------------------------
Who owns the asset? Your business (from day 1) Finance company
Asset on your balance sheet? Yes Yes (under AASB 16)
GST claim on purchase Full GST claimable upfront GST claimed on each lease payment
Depreciation claim Yes (if asset depreciates) No (but lease payments deductible)
Interest component deductible? Yes N/A — lease payments are deductible
Residual / balloon? Optional Usually mandatory
FBT implications (personal use) May apply May apply
Early termination More flexible Can incur break costs
PPSR registration Lender registers over asset Finance company is registered owner
GST Treatment
This is often the deciding factor for registered businesses.
Chattel Mortgage:
- If the total cost (including GST) is financed, your business can claim the full input tax credit (ITC) upfront in the BAS period of purchase
- This improves cash flow — you get the GST back before you've finished paying for the asset
Finance Lease:
- GST is claimed spread across each lease payment over the term
- For assets purchased below the instant asset write-off threshold, a chattel mortgage often has the cash flow advantage
Always confirm the GST treatment with your accountant — it depends on your specific registration status and how the deal is structured.
Depreciation and Tax Deductions
Chattel Mortgage:
- As asset owner, your business can claim depreciation through your tax return
- Interest on the loan is deductible as a business expense
- Under the Temporary Full Expensing (TFE) provisions (check current ATO status), eligible businesses could immediately write off the full cost of eligible assets
Finance Lease:
- You're not the owner, so you can't claim depreciation
- Instead, each lease payment is fully deductible as a business expense
- For businesses with lower tax positions or those who prefer simplicity, lease deductions may be equivalent or simpler
Balance Sheet Treatment
Under AASB 16 (effective since 2019), most leases must be recognised on the balance sheet — so the clean "off-balance sheet" advantage of leasing no longer applies in most cases. Both structures will appear on your balance sheet in some form.
This makes the comparison more about cash flow timing, GST, and tax treatment than raw accounting appearance.
Which Is More Common for Businesses?
Chattel mortgages are more common for:
- Commercial vehicles (utes, vans, trucks)
- Earthmoving and construction equipment
- Business owner-operators who want to own the asset outright
- Businesses with strong cash flow wanting to maximise early tax deductions
Finance leases are more common for:
- Technology and equipment with high obsolescence risk
- Businesses that prefer to upgrade assets regularly
- Situations where keeping cash available is the priority
- Fleets where flexible end-of-term options are valued
What About Hire Purchase (Commercial Hire Purchase)?
There's a third structure worth mentioning: commercial hire purchase (CHP).
Similar to a chattel mortgage, CHP involves regular payments and ownership transferring to your business at the end of the term. The key difference is in the legal structure — the finance company technically hires the asset to you, with title transferring on final payment. For most businesses, CHP and chattel mortgage are functionally similar; the preferred structure depends on the lender and your accountant's advice.
A Worked Example
You need to finance a $80,000 (ex-GST) truck for your trades business.
Option A — Chattel Mortgage:
- Loan amount: $88,000 (including $8,000 GST)
- Claim $8,000 ITC in next BAS (immediate cash return)
- Claim depreciation on $80,000 over vehicle life
- Interest deductible over term
- Own the truck from day one
Option B — Finance Lease:
- Lease payments include a portion of GST each payment
- Claim each payment as a deduction
- No depreciation claim
- Finance company owns the truck until end-of-lease purchase
For a profitable business with cash flow, Option A typically provides better total tax outcomes — but your accountant should model both based on your tax position.
Key Questions to Ask Before Financing an Asset
1. What is the business's tax position? — Higher-profit businesses benefit more from immediate deductibility
2. Is there a GST registration? — Non-registered businesses can't claim ITCs, which changes the comparison
3. How long will you keep the asset? — Long term = chattel mortgage advantage; short term or upgrade-heavy = lease advantage
4. What is your cash flow situation? — Both can be structured with similar repayments; GST timing is the key cash flow difference
5. Does FBT apply? — If employees use the asset privately, FBT implications need to be considered regardless of structure
Work With Your Accountant and Broker Together
The best outcome comes from your commercial finance broker handling the lender selection and rate negotiation, while your accountant advises on the optimal structure for your tax position.
At Freedom Financing, we work alongside your accountant and provide clear comparisons so you can make an informed decision — not just take what the dealer's finance desk offers.
---
This article is general in nature and does not constitute financial or tax advice. Structures should be confirmed with your accountant before proceeding. All lending is subject to credit assessment and approval. Freedom Financing Pty Ltd holds Australian Credit Licence 384704.